Book Review: Becoming Abolitionists

 

Image: The cover of the book is a black background. At the center is a realistic illustration of a police car. There are stylized flames bursting from the car which turn into vines and multi colored bunches of flowers. Across the top in large white letters is "becoming abolitionists." Below that in smaller yellow letters is, "Police protests, and the pursuit of freedom." Across the bottom in red letters is the author's name, "Derecka Purnell."

 

Becoming Abolitionists is likely the best modern book on prison abolition, as well as dismantling oppression at large, that I have read. I say "best modern book" because it is true that Purnell goes over ground that those who have come before her have as well. The big difference in this book for me is its inclusivity and centering of LGBTQ and Disabled people in these discussions and the poetic descriptions and analogies Purnell uses to examine these issues. It made the book feel fresh, as if I was hearing all of it for the first time.

As is expected, Purnell discusses the myriad of issues with the prison industrial complex as well as how poverty and oppression can mix together and cause our communities to become separated, lack trust, and to look to hierarchy- and agents of hierarchy such as police and prisons- for solutions. The detrimental effects of these things disproportionately affect Black, Brown, Indigenous, Disabled, poor, and LGBTQ populations- especially those who have multiple of these frequently overlapping experiences and identities. Purnell draws upon her experience as both a lawyer and an organizer and offers an extensive amount of suggestions. She addresses all of the big questions about what to do with those who commit violence on others and so forth. She gets down to many root causes of problems and always remains humble about whether or not things will work in all situations or whether or not she has all of the answers. She shares a lot about her own journey in resisting, coming to understand, and eventually believing in and fighting for abolition which helps put the reader at ease with their own challenging thoughts or feelings that may come up while reading the book.

Where this book surprised me was in its sections on LGBTQ folks and disabled folks. These sections are far more thorough than other books I have read about abolition that were not specifically focused on disabled or lgbtq people. There was impressive amount of detail in the section on disability as there should be in these discussions. Purnell also does not draw clear lines in the sand between demographics of people despite these focuses. She instead discusses how all of these overlapping communities can come together in solidarity rather than turning on one another or forcing people to separate out sections of themselves at odds with various communities as those with the most power prefer us to. 

Pittsburgh (my city) also makes an appearance when she interviewed local organizers and studied efforts in the area. She got the history spot on. It's bittersweet to see my city featured because I am both very glad the awareness has been raised and the amazing radical movements here are being noticed. But, there is a reason this city is noticed and it's because of the horrors these organizers are often responding to.

I did have a gripe here or there about how she assessed an institution or particular chunk of data, but that happens in pretty much any book I read. I do think she could have gone easier on social workers and foster parents. The system is flawed and oppressive, but it sort of read like she believes social workers get into it or primarily do their jobs to strengthen the system or for the money which is odd to say about a highly stressful, underpaid job that requires going into a good bit of student debt to qualify for. The discussions about whether or not children should be removed from households made me bristle. Particularly because I did not find the solutions offered for one example she gave to be adequate and also because I have seen severely abused kids be kept with parents who could not have cared less about them, or worse things I won't detail. However, the larger systemic changes offered would likely solve or greatly reduce the issues, so her real life example given still fits into the journey. She also acknowledges that even some abolitionist readers would believe the children should be removed and that she does not have a perfect answer for that. That's, again, a strength of the book. She offers a massive amount of workable, applicable solutions that could be implemented right now. She also acknowledges that these may work, not work, or look different in different communities.

Overall, I really loved this book, how it was written, and the information therein. It can be hard to "enjoy" a book that contains so much suffering. The fact that it features often hidden parts of the story as well as tangible lights at the end of the tunnels is what makes it all worthwhile.

This was also posted to my goodreads.